🥚 I Put Humpty Dumpty Back Together Wrong (#364)
He was not good as new. He was good as afterward.
By the time I arrived, Humpty Dumpty had already fallen off the wall.
This was unfortunate for Humpty, but extremely convenient for the rhyme, which appeared to have been waiting for exactly this kind of development.
All the king’s horses and all the king’s men were gathered around him in a large, official-looking circle. Several were shaking their heads. One was taking notes. Another was holding a trumpet for reasons no one seemed prepared to defend.
Humpty lay in pieces on the ground.
The men looked solemn.
The horses looked like horses.
“No use,” said the captain of the king’s men. “He cannot be put back together again.”
“Did anyone bring glue?” I asked.
The captain looked offended.
They had brought twelve horses, forty-seven men, a trumpet, ceremonial rope, three clipboards, and a small banner reading ROYAL RESPONSE UNIT.
They had not brought adhesive.
I was appalled by the staffing model.
🐴 Too Many Horses, Not Enough Glue
“Why are the horses here?” I asked.
“They are the king’s horses,” said the captain.
“Yes, but what are their qualifications?”
The captain stared at me as if I had questioned the monarchy, the rhyme, and perhaps horse ownership in general.
“They are extremely royal.”
“That is not a qualification.”
One of the horses bent down and sniffed a piece of Humpty’s shell.
“Please don’t eat that,” I said.
The horse ate it.
This immediately complicated the inventory.
The king’s men began discussing whether the missing fragment should be listed as consumed, misplaced, or absorbed into the cavalry. A new clipboard was requested.
Meanwhile, Humpty’s pieces remained on the ground.
This is a common feature of organized response: the paperwork becomes increasingly detailed while the broken person continues lying there.
I borrowed the trumpet player’s empty hat, which seemed to be contributing nothing else to the emergency, and began placing Humpty’s pieces inside.
“Where are you taking him?” asked the captain.
“My kitchen.”
“You are not authorized to relocate royal egg matter.”
“Do you have glue?”
“No.”
“Then you’re not in charge. You’re just standing near the problem in a nicer jacket.”
🧴 Reconstruction Without Instructions
I placed Humpty’s pieces across my kitchen table.
There were more of them than I had expected.
An egg seems like one uncomplicated object right up until it becomes thirty-seven urgent little decisions. The yolk, meanwhile, had committed fully to the concept of being everywhere.
I arranged the largest pieces first. The smaller ones went into bowls labeled LEFT SIDE, FACE, and BITS THAT WOULD BECOME IMPORTANT THE MOMENT I THREW THEM AWAY.
There were no instructions.
There are rarely instructions for becoming yourself again.
I used super glue for structure, gold lacquer for dignity, and one strip of duct tape for morale.
The duct tape was not strictly necessary, but morale seldom is until it disappears.
Halfway through the repair, I discovered we were missing a significant piece near Humpty’s lower right side.
I searched the kitchen.
I searched the garden.
I searched the horse, although the horse objected to the tone of the examination.
The king’s men searched for additional forms.
The fragment was gone.
Fortunately, I owned an old biscuit tin.
It had once contained shortbread and now contained buttons, dead batteries, two keys that opened nothing, and the kind of string people save because throwing away string feels reckless.
I cut a curved piece from the lid and fitted it into the gap.
It did not match.
It had a small painted picture of a Scottish castle on it.
I considered this an improvement.
When the final piece was attached, I stepped back.
Humpty was together.
Not symmetrically.
His left eyebrow sat slightly higher than the right. One side of his mouth suggested suspicion. The other suggested he had just remembered an unpaid bill.
Gold seams ran across his shell.
The biscuit tin patch gleamed near his hip.
He looked magnificent.
He also looked like something assembled during a power outage by a man who had recently inhaled glue.
Both things can be true.
✨ Everyone Could See Where He Broke
Humpty opened his eyes.
He looked at me.
Then he looked down at himself.
“What do you call this?”
“I put you back together.”
“You have reassembled me,” he said. “That is not the same as restoring me.”
“That was the available method.”
He demanded a mirror.
I hesitated, which did not improve his mood.
When he saw the gold lines, his face collapsed into horror.
“Everyone can see the evidence.”
“The cracks?” I asked.
“They are not cracks,” Humpty said. “They are visible resilience channels.”
“They look like cracks.”
“That is because you are using the word carelessly.”
“Whatever you call them,” I said, “they show that you survived.”
“Survival is a private matter. Presentation is public.”
For a moment, the room became quiet.
The gold seams caught the afternoon light. Humpty studied them.
It was almost meaningful.
Then he noticed his eyebrow.
“Why is my face expressing two opinions?”
“The glue dried before I could line up your left eyebrow,” I explained.
“It is not crooked,” he said. “It is asymmetrically authoritative.”
“And this?” He pointed to the biscuit tin patch.
“We were missing a piece.”
“That is not shell.”
“It is a biscuit tin,” I said.
“Then call it decorative reinforcement.”
“It is still a biscuit tin.”
“Only if you insist on using the least flattering word available.”
“That describes most adulthood: mismatched parts renamed with confidence.”
Humpty glared at me.
People assume a traumatic fall will make someone gentle, grateful, and full of perspective. This is not always the case. Sometimes it makes them the same difficult person, only with what Humpty insisted were “visible resilience channels.”
Before the fall, Humpty had been vain, argumentative, and extremely invested in the smoothness of his shell. After the fall, he remained all three, but now with gold seams, an asymmetrically authoritative eyebrow, and what he called “an imported decorative panel” embedded in his lower body.
Recovery does not always improve the personality.
Sometimes it simply returns the personality to service.
📋 The Restoration Critics Arrive
The king’s men appeared at my door the following morning.
They had brought the horses again.
They had not brought breakfast.
The captain inspected Humpty from several angles.
“The gold is not historically accurate,” he said.
“It is not decoration,” Humpty replied. “It is visible evidence of restoration.”
“He was previously in pieces,” I said.
“Yes, but traditionally colored pieces,” the captain replied.
Another man tapped the biscuit tin patch with a pencil.
“Imported decorative panel,” Humpty noted.
“This may affect his resale value.”
“He is not a side table,” I said.
“That has not been officially determined.”
A third man asked whether I had obtained royal permission before reassembling taxable property.
Humpty was sitting beside them, fully conscious, while they discussed his value, accuracy, and legal status as if he were a damaged vase discovered in a palace basement.
“Revised,” he said. “Not damaged.”
I have noticed that institutions often arrive after the emotional labor is complete and become very concerned about the finish.
The king’s men formed a small review panel.
One preferred the gold.
One called it indulgent.
One suggested painting over the seams so no one would know what had happened.
“You do not conceal a revised edition,” Humpty said. “You charge more for it.”
Humpty looked at me.
For the first time since waking, he seemed less vain than tired.
“Can they really paint over me?” he asked.
“No.”
“How do you know?”
“I have hidden the paint.”
This is not legal expertise.
It is jurisprudence by hiding the bucket.
📣 Healing Acquires a Marketing Department
Humpty’s opinion of the repair changed once other people began admiring it.
At first, he covered the gold seams with a scarf.
Then a woman in the village called him “striking.”
A child said the cracks looked like lightning.
A merchant offered to paint his portrait.
By Thursday, Humpty had stopped hiding the seams.
By Friday, he had developed a personal brand.
“I am not broken,” he announced. “Broken is an imprecise word. I am a revised edition.”
This troubled me.
He launched a lecture series called:
JUST SPIRAL FORWARD: PREMIUM REASSEMBLY EDITION
The first event took place in the town hall.
One seminar was titled Finding the Yolk Within. I left before the Q&A.
Humpty stood beneath a banner showing an enlarged image of his own face. He spoke for forty minutes about “transforming unauthorized descent into visible radiance.”
“Your greatest weakness can become your greatest strength,” Humpty told the audience.
“Your deepest wound can become your greatest gift.”
“Your yolk can become your yoke.”
At that point I stopped taking notes.
He began correcting anyone who called them cracks.
“They are visible resilience channels,” he said. “A crack is merely a resilience channel described by someone without vision.”
“They are still cracks,” I said.
“Only physically,” Humpty replied. “Conceptually, they are premium features.”
This was the moment I realized healing had acquired a sales department.
He sold miniature gold repair kits in the lobby.
The kits contained glitter, glue, and a card that read:
YOUR DAMAGE IS YOUR DIFFERENTIATOR
I bought one out of professional concern.
The glue had already sealed the box shut.
The king’s men immediately announced that Humpty’s recovery had been a successful royal initiative. They unveiled a new banner:
THE KINGDOM CARES: REASSEMBLY THROUGH LEADERSHIP
The horses received medals.
I received an invoice for unauthorized biscuit-tin use.
Humpty’s lectures became popular.
He began telling audiences that his fall had not been a fall at all.
“It was an unauthorized descent,” he explained, “followed by a restoration of rank.”
He also began calling it “the greatest opportunity of his life.”
This was not what he had said while lying in fragments.
I regretted teaching him the word “resilience.”
He had promoted it beyond its qualifications.
🧱 Humpty Goes Back to the Wall
Several weeks later, I found Humpty climbing the wall again.
He had nearly reached the top.
“What are you doing?” I shouted.
“Returning.”
“To the wall?”
“Resuming my position. I like the view.”
“You fell from there.”
“I descended unexpectedly.”
“You shattered.”
“I became temporarily plural.”
“And now you are climbing back up.”
Humpty stopped and looked down at me.
The gold seams ran across him in the sunlight. The biscuit tin castle flashed near his side.
“I was restored,” he said. “That does not make you my custodian.”
“You were repaired.”
“Restored is the word I am using.”
Annoyingly, the inflated vocabulary contained a real point. I was not his custodian.
I wanted to tell him that surviving one fall did not make him unbreakable.
I wanted to tell him that the glue had limitations.
I wanted to tell him that the biscuit tin section was not load-bearing, despite its confidence.
Instead, I watched him climb.
After helping someone gather their pieces, there’s a temptation to mistake care for authority. You have not earned a vote in everything they do next.
Repair is not ownership.
Care is not a leash.
Humpty reached the top of the wall and sat down.
He looked over the kingdom.
He looked pleased.
I placed six cushions beneath him.
Then two mattresses.
Then a basket of dinner rolls, which offered little structural value but made me feel more involved.
The king’s men called this excessive.
The same horse ate one of the cushions.
Humpty remained on the wall.
Not good as new.
Not as he had been.
Revised, restored, reassembled—depending on who was speaking.
Good as afterward.
🧂 Crumb of Meaning
Being put back together does not mean becoming who you were before.
Sometimes the repair shows.
Sometimes a piece is missing.
Sometimes part of you is now a biscuit tin.
Sometimes your life has leaked all over the floor and somebody is trying to describe it as growth.
You are still allowed to like the view.
🤖 Disclaimer
This account was developed with assistance from artificial intelligence, excessive adhesive, and a reconstruction method not recognized by any royal medical board. No horses were qualified for the positions they occupied. Gold lacquer should not be mistaken for emotional closure, structural certification, or permission to monetize your collapse.
🍪 Serving Suggestion
Consume after a fall, beside a soft cushion and someone who brought glue instead of a clipboard.
Just Spiral Forward? That’s MY idea!
If you don’t know by now that you should buy the t-shirt, I don’t know what to tell you.
If you don’t know by now that you should buy the t-shirt, I don’t know what to tell you.
Check out the Thaddeus J. Butterwell line of merch!
Coming Soon!
The book you didn’t know you needed… because denial is one of your core coping skills.
The astute among you may notice the cover has slightly changed.
